Before America Was 250: Protecting the Places That Hold Our History

In 2026, the United States commemorates 250 years since the signing of the Declaration of Independence. The semi quincentennial provides an opportunity to reflect on the history of the United States, the development of its institutions, and the physical places that have come to represent the American experience. Yet 250 years is a relatively short period within the much longer human history of the lands and waters that now comprise the United States. Long before 1776, Tribal Nations governed themselves, maintained diplomatic and economic relationships, raised families, practiced religions and ceremonies, and developed complex relationships with particular landscapes and waterways.

For Tribal Nations, this history is not merely archaeological or historical. It is living history maintained through oral traditions, cultural practices, languages, ceremonies, kinship systems, and continuing relationships with ancestral places. These histories belong to the Tribal Nations and Native peoples who have carried them across generations, but they also form an essential part of the broader history of the United States. Tribal history is part of the American story, and that story is much older than America itself.

A Landscape Transformed in 250 Years

The physical landscape of the United States has changed dramatically during the past 250 years. Rivers have been dammed, diverted, dredged, and channelized. Wetlands have been drained, forests cleared, prairies converted to agricultural production, mountains mined, and coastlines altered. Railroads, highways, pipelines, transmission corridors, reservoirs, military installations, cities, agricultural systems, and other forms of development have permanently transformed millions of acres.

For Tribal Nations, these changes have had consequences extending well beyond the physical alteration of land. Reservoir construction has inundated ancestral villages, burial areas, gathering places, and culturally significant landscapes. Transportation and energy infrastructure have fragmented other places. Agricultural development, mining, urban expansion, and federal land management have transformed landscapes that contain evidence of Native occupation as well as places that continue to possess religious, cultural, and historical significance.

The alteration of a landscape, however, does not erase its history. A modern highway may cross an ancestral village or migration route. A reservoir shoreline may contain burial places. A transmission corridor may intersect a traditional cultural landscape. A seemingly undeveloped mountain, prairie, riverbank, or forest may remain a place of prayer, ceremony, gathering, origin, or remembrance. The absence of a building, monument, or historical marker does not mean the absence of history.

This is an important consideration as the United States reflects upon its first 250 years. Much of the physical landscape familiar to Americans today is comparatively recent. Beneath and within that contemporary landscape is a much older record of human presence, governance, spirituality, movement, survival, and community.

Section 106 and the Recognition of a Deeper History

Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act establishes a process through which federal agencies must consider the effects of federal undertakings on historic properties. The process includes consultation with Tribal Nations when undertakings may affect properties of religious and cultural significance to them. Although Section 106 is sometimes approached primarily as a regulatory or archaeological process, its significance for Tribal Nations is considerably broader.

Federal and state inventories cannot contain the entirety of Indigenous history. Archaeological surveys provide important information, but archaeology alone cannot determine the cultural significance of a place. Written records may also be incomplete, particularly when those records were created by governments or institutions that historically excluded Native voices. Tribal Nations possess knowledge derived from oral history, ceremony, kinship, traditional ecological knowledge, cultural practice, and generations of relationships with particular places.

This is why meaningful Tribal consultation is fundamental to the Section 106 process. A federal agency cannot assume that the absence of a recorded archaeological site means that a place lacks cultural significance. Nor can contemporary reservation boundaries be treated as the geographic limits of a Tribal Nation's historical interests. Forced removal, treaty-making, land cessions, allotment, relocation, and other federal policies displaced Native peoples from extensive ancestral territories, but those governmental actions did not extinguish historical, cultural, or spiritual relationships with those lands.

Burial Places and Our Responsibility to the Ancestors

The responsibilities associated with historic preservation become particularly significant when federal undertakings or development activities encounter Native burial places or human remains. Within regulatory processes, human remains may sometimes be discussed using technical terms associated with archaeology, cultural resources, or inadvertent discoveries. For Tribal Nations, however, the fundamental relationship is more direct: these are our relatives and ancestors.

The people buried within these landscapes were members of families, communities, and Nations. Their resting places reflect cultural and spiritual practices that deserve respect regardless of whether those places are marked according to contemporary Western conventions. Many Native burial places were established long before county boundaries, property records, federal land designations, or modern development patterns existed.

The treatment of Native graves therefore raises questions extending beyond technical compliance. When human remains are encountered, the principal concern should not simply be how quickly a project can resume. The process should recognize the dignity of the deceased, the rights and responsibilities of descendant communities, applicable federal and state law, and the governmental relationship between the United States and Tribal Nations.

Preserving burial places also requires recognizing that many remain unidentified within conventional databases. The absence of a cemetery marker or documentary record should never be interpreted as proof that a landscape contains no graves. Early consultation with Tribal Nations can provide information and cultural context that may not be available through conventional archival or archaeological research.

Sacred Places and Cultural Landscapes

Indigenous sacred places do not always correspond to Western concepts of historic preservation. A place of profound cultural or religious significance may contain no standing structure, architectural feature, or visible evidence that would immediately communicate its importance to an outside observer. It may instead be a river, spring, mountain, bluff, cave, prairie, gathering area, stone formation, trail, burial area, or an interconnected landscape encompassing many individual places.

Understanding these landscapes requires a broader conception of historic significance. A sacred site cannot always be separated from the surrounding environment, and a culturally significant landscape cannot necessarily be understood by dividing it into individual archaeological sites. Water, plants, animals, viewsheds, travel routes, burial places, and ceremonial areas may together form a cultural landscape whose significance exists precisely because of the relationships among its parts.

This is also why consultation must occur early enough to influence federal decision-making. Consultation undertaken after a preferred route has been selected, engineering completed, or substantial resources committed to a project substantially limits the opportunity for meaningful consideration of alternatives. The objective should not merely be to document damage after it becomes unavoidable. Whenever practicable, the first consideration should be whether adverse effects can be avoided.

An American Story Older Than America

America's 250th anniversary provides an opportunity to reconsider how the Nation defines and preserves its history. The American story did not begin in 1776. The lands upon which the United States was established already contained thousands of years of human history, including systems of government, diplomacy, commerce, agriculture, environmental stewardship, religion, language, conflict, migration, and community.

Recognizing this deeper history does not diminish the significance of the events that occurred during the past 250 years. Rather, it places them within a more complete historical framework. The history of the United States cannot be fully understood without understanding the peoples, governments, landscapes, and histories that preceded its establishment and continued after it.

In this sense, protecting Tribal historic places is not solely about preserving “Tribal history” as a separate category of the American experience. These places help tell the American story because the American story is rooted in landscapes whose human histories extend thousands of years beyond the existence of the United States. When an ancestral village, burial place, sacred landscape, or culturally significant waterway is permanently destroyed, something is lost not only to the Tribal Nation connected to that place, but also from the historical record of this country.

Preserving the Landscape for the Next 250 Years

The 250th anniversary also invites a forward-looking question: What will remain when the United States reaches its 500th anniversary? The transformation that has occurred since 1776 demonstrates how quickly landscapes can change and how permanent those changes can become. The decisions made by governments, industries, communities, and individuals today will determine what physical evidence of our collective history remains available to future generations.

Historic preservation therefore should not be understood simply as an effort to document what existed before development occurred. Documentation has value, but a report, photograph, archaeological inventory, or historical marker cannot always substitute for the continued existence of the place itself. Future generations should have opportunities to experience culturally and historically significant landscapes as places rather than know them only through records describing what once existed.

This principle is particularly important for Tribal Nations because relationships with ancestral places are often intergenerational. Cultural knowledge can be transmitted through language and oral tradition, but it is also transmitted by being present on the land: visiting a place, gathering medicines, observing waterways, conducting ceremonies, telling stories where events occurred, and teaching younger generations their responsibilities to those places. When the physical place disappears, an important dimension of cultural transmission can disappear with it.

Section 106 is therefore more than a procedural requirement within federal project development. Properly implemented, it provides an opportunity to identify what may otherwise remain unseen, bring Tribal knowledge into federal decision-making, consider alternatives before irreversible decisions are made, and determine whether adverse effects can be avoided, minimized, or appropriately addressed. Its effectiveness depends upon federal agencies approaching consultation as a substantive government-to-government responsibility rather than a procedural requirement to be completed.

What We Choose to Leave Behind

As the United States commemorates its first 250 years, there is value in remembering that the Nation itself occupies only a brief period within the history of these lands. There were governments before there were states, trade and travel routes before interstate highways, sacred places before national parks, communities before modern cities, and Indigenous names and understandings of rivers and mountains long before those features appeared on American maps.

Generations of Native people also lived and were laid to rest across these lands long before the political boundaries of the United States were established. Their histories remain present within landscapes that Americans encounter every day, even when those histories are not immediately visible.

Protecting these places should therefore be understood as both a Tribal and national responsibility. The stories, landscapes, waterways, burial places, sacred spaces, and cultural places of Tribal Nations are part of the historical inheritance of this country. They tell a story that is American, even though it began long before there was an America.

The preservation decisions made today will determine what future generations inherit. Two hundred and fifty years from now, they may have our reports, photographs, maps, and written histories. The more consequential question is whether they will also have the rivers, landscapes, burial places, sacred spaces, and culturally significant places from which those histories emerged.

As America reflects upon its first 250 years, historic preservation asks us to consider our responsibility for the next 250. Our obligation should be not merely to preserve the stories of these places, but, wherever possible, to preserve the places themselves so that future generations can know them, learn from them, and carry their histories forward.

Next
Next

From Recommendations to Legislation: Advancing The Way Forward Through the Native Children’s Commission Implementation Act